login   |    register
Astra Scale Models [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEBSITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

Built Review
172
Rubble Piles
Piles of Rubble Diorama Accessory
  • move

by: Jan Etal [ TREAD_GEEK ]


Originally published on:
Armorama

Introduction

Through a fluke of circumstance this reviewer stumbled onto a small company, Astra Scale Models, that specializes in the production of Braille Scale diorama bases and accessories. While not new to the scene they have until now gone largely unnoticed. Their products are perfectly suited to the modeller whose build preferences lie in the 1/76 or 1/72 scales.

As a small (Braille) scale modeller it is often difficult to find accessories to use during a build. Most often local shops will cater to larger scales and in particular the model railroad crowd. Add in the fact that even with all the scenic materials available, the new or inexperienced builder desiring to create a diorama or vignette may lack the skills necessary to achieve their goal.

As the builders of model military vehicles well know, the nature of conflict eventually leads to the disfigurement or destruction of much in their path. Think of all the photographs of vehicles against a backdrop of ruins and the general rubble created by war. Enter Astra with their unique offering of a resin based set of ten varying piles of rubble and crud that will represent instant heaps of debris for your diorama base.

This review shall focus on the Astra 72-Acc-4 set of ten piles of rubble and debris.

Contents

This product arrives in a plastic zip-lock bag that contains the resin casting and a folded four sided cardboard stiffener or insert. On the casting lives the ten piles of rubble and debris with four specifically meant to fit inside corners.

On the cardboard insert are two pages of what might be termed instructions. One section labelled “Notes:” are general instructions for dealing with their bases or accessories. The second page outlines a suggested finishing process.

The Set

The piles are attached on a single piece casting that measures 5 1/2 X 1 1/2 inches (13.5 X 3.8 cm). Each individual pile is solid resin moulded in an off white colour. There were a few small air bubbles under some of the piles, but in all cases they were toward the centre of the pile and on the bottom that wouldn’t be exposed. The base material that the piles are attached to should present little to no problems during their removal as the thickness is barely .5 mm.

All ten piles vary in size and composition with each having its own unique features. In examining the details of the piles one can find many diverse items. These range from typical pieces of bricks, blocks and lumber to a tire protruding from the base bottom, to an errant half buried jerrycan or wine bottle. Astra must be commended on the amount of detail that they have managed to present in these heaps and at this small a scale.

Finishing

While not having a definite purpose in mind, I was intrigued enough by this set that I decided to try my hand at finishing one. The first instruction of the finishing process was to clean the resin. For this I followed their suggestion and washed the resin with mild dish washing soap. This is always a good idea even with plastic kits in order to remove any residual mould release agent. After rinsing the casting well I allowed it to air dry thoroughly.

The next suggested step was to prime all the piles. Astra suggests using either an earth, tan or grey colour for this process. The colour will vary depending on geographical location and construction materials to be represented. For the base of my piles I used a Humbrol #29 Dark Earth enamel.

The next steps involve painting individual details with appropriate colours. Following their suggestions I dry-brushed to add highlights and shade and then several light washes to further accentuate details. The exact process will vary with modeller and the setting for the pieces.

The instructions provide further detailing instructions such as using pastel chalks, pigments or other media to enhance the finished product. Once satisfied the modeller is advised to coat the finished pieces with a flat base for protection.

Conclusions

I only wish I had discovered products like these years ago. My attempts to create vignettes or dioramas in the past have all been less than successful. I can see the effort that was required to create these rather extremely detailed pieces. For such a simple subject they could be beyond the ability of a novice or even moderately skilled modeller to create. At the very least it would be quite time consuming. Even for the advanced modeller their use would most likely be a great time saver. Compared to other resin accessories their cost is fairly low. So, what is not to recommend?

My thanks to Astra Scale Models for providing the review sample. Further, I would also like to acknowledge them for their time and assistance in providing information and details of their products.

SUMMARY
Highs: At times, almost unbelievable detail for the scale. Very reasonable cost.
Lows: Not really any that I could think of.
Verdict: What’s not to like. Reasonable cost and a real time saver. Recommended.
Percentage Rating
95%
  Scale: 1:72
  Mfg. ID: 72-Acc-4
  Suggested Retail: $3.00
  Related Link: 
  PUBLISHED: Nov 23, 2010
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 84.51%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 93.50%

About Jan Etal (tread_geek)
FROM: ONTARIO, CANADA

I've been building models since about age 10 with the occasional hiatus due to real life events. First armour model was a 1/76 Airfix Tiger I and was followed by a 1/72 Revell F4U Corsair. I've built primarily 1/76 and 1/72 armour and aircraft but occasionally have tinkered in other larger scales....

Copyright ©2019 text by Jan Etal [ TREAD_GEEK ]. Images also by copyright holder unless otherwise noted. Opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of AeroScale. All rights reserved.



Comments

They look like an Aero chocolate bar with all those air holes!
DEC 07, 2010 - 05:01 AM
I am sorry Jan I agree with Biggles2 in so much as if it was not for the low price I would demand a replacement due to the number of air bubbles in the moulding. You have stated that they are not a new company and as such I would have expected a better finish from them.
DEC 07, 2010 - 05:18 AM
Gentlemen, thank you for your comments and observations. I have relayed them to the manufacturer despite the fact that I am not totally in agreement with them. After all, these piles are refuse and junk and general garbage. Any anomaly could be dismissed as generally assisting in the overall effect. I must also take some blame for my limitations and inability to do justice to these pieces. I purposely ignored applying several small "finishing touches" to the final product that were recommended in the instructions. Namely, utilizing fine gravel, clay crumbs, ground cat litter and other minor treatments to enhance the effect. One last point that I would like to make is that the photos of the "unenhanced" piles were taken with a 4X macro lens! The pile in the original announcement post is in reality 30 mm wide by 12 mm high. On my monitor the photo measures out at 200 mm wide by 140 mm high (8"X5.5"). Would most people even imagine what they would look like to the naked eye. Again, thanks for looking. I cannot speak for the manufacturer but I shall post any comment from Astra upon receipt of same. Cheers, Jan
DEC 13, 2010 - 09:09 AM
Sorry I couldn´t dismiss this ... Id agree with Darren and Biggles ... these are very poor. An interesting idea, but in reality hardly worth paying money for. The only thing that stands out, is the barrel and wheel buried in the piles. The rest can be easily made by any modeller, at any level ... and be built to suit/fit your scene as well. In my opinion 20% would be kind for this product. I mean how hard is it to make a small pile of stones, and set a wheel and barrel in it? On the other hand if they took the idea and improved it with more/better details, it would be worth considering. Some of their other items ... in comparison .... look much better. In honesty, considering the quality and usefulness of a lot of aftermarket items that are available today, giving this item 95% is missleading. Im hoping that the fact that your address and Astra´s are both in Ontario, has nothing to do with your evaluation.
DEC 13, 2010 - 12:37 PM
   

What's Your Opinion?


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move
  • move